72
environmental stress and biochemical degradation, min lSTRs can be used for
over routine STR because of shorter amplicon size.
DNA Profiling is a complicated process and each sequential step involved in
generating a profile can vary depending on the facilities available In the
laboratory. The analysis principles, however, remain similar, which include:
1. isolation, purification & quantitation of DNA
2. amplification of selected genetic markers
3. visualising the fragments and genotyping
4. statistical analysis & interpretation.
In mtDNA analysis, variations in Hypervariable Region I & II (HVR I & II) are
detected by sequencing and comparing results with control samples:….
Statistical Analysis
Atypical DNA case involves comparison of evidence samples, such as semen from
a rape, and known or reference samples, such as a blood sample from a suspect.
Generally, there are three possible outcomes of profile comparison:
1) Match: If the DNA profiles obtained from the two samples are
indistinguishable, they are said to have matched.
2) Exclusion: If the comparison of profiles shows differences, it can only be
explained by the two samples originating from different sources.
3) Inconclusive: The data does not support a conclusion Of the three possible
outcomes, only the "match" between samples needs to be supported by statistical
calculation. Statistics attempt to provide meaning to the match. The match
statistics are usually provided as an estimate of the Random Match Probability
(RMP) or in other words, the frequency of the particular DNA profile in a
population.
In case of paternity/maternity testing, exclusion at more than two loci is
considered exclusion. An allowance of 1 or 2 loci possible mutations should be
taken Into consideration while reporting a match. Paternity of Maternity Indices
and Likelihood Ratios are calculated further to support the match.
Collection and Preservation of Evidence
If DNA evidence is not properly documented, collected, packaged, and preserved,
It will not meet the legal and scientific requirements for admissibility in. a court
of law. Because extremely small samples of DNA can be used as evidence, greater
attention to contamination issues is necessary while locating, collecting, and
preserving DNA evidence can be contaminated when DNA from another source
gets mixed with DNA relevant to the case. This can happen when someone sneezes
or coughs over the evidence or touches his/her mouth, nose, or other part of the
face and then touches area that may contain the DNA to be tested. The exhibits
having biological specimen, which can establish link among victim(s), suspect(s),
scene of crime for solving the case should be Identified, preserved, packed and
sent for DNA Profiling.”
135. In an earlier judgment, R v Dohoney & Adams41 the UK Court of Appeal
laid down the following guidelines concerning the procedure for introducing
DNA evidence in trials: (1) the scientist should adduce the evidence of the DNA
41 1997 (1) Crl App Rep 369
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents