which the cause of that person's death comes into
question. Such statements are relevant whether the
person who made them was or was not, at the time
when they were made, under expectation of death, and
whatever may be the nature of the proceeding in which
the cause of his death comes into question.” (emphasis
added).
In Pius Jasunga s/o Akumu v. The Queen it was pointed out
(for the reason associated with the italicised words in the
subsection) that the weight to be attached to a dying
declaration admitted by reference to section 32 of the Indian
Evidence Act 1872 would necessarily be less than that
attached to a dying declaration admitted under the common
law rules. The first kind of statement would lack that special
quality that is thought to surround a declaration made by a
dying man who was conscious of his condition and who had
given up all hope of survival. Accordingly it may not seem
surprising that the courts dealing with such statements have
felt the need to exercise even more caution in the use to be
made of them than is the case where the common law test is
applied."”
57.
This Court in Muthu Kutty & Anr. v. State by Inspector of Police,
T.N. reported in (2005) 9 SCC 113, while discussing the decision in
Woodcock (supra) referred to above had cautioned the courts to ensure that
a dying declaration is reliable before relying on it, with the following
observations: “13. … The general principle on which this species of evidence
is admitted is that they are declarations made in extremity,
when the party is at the point of death and when every hope of
this world is gone, when every motive to falsehood is silenced,
and the mind is induced by the most powerful considerations
to speak the truth; a situation so solemn and so lawful is
considered by the law as creating an obligation equal to that
which is imposed by a positive oath administered in a court of
justice. These aspects have been eloquently stated by Eyre,
L.C.B. in R. v. Woodcock ((1789) 1 Leah 500 : 168 ER 352).
Shakespeare makes the wounded Melun, finding himself
28
選擇目標文字3
連接到段落
連接到實體
取消高亮顯示
新增到目錄